Showing posts with label debate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label debate. Show all posts

Friday, January 28, 2011

Rebuttal to Alyssa

In Alyssa's topic about the number of required years of school, her thesis states that, “the number of years of required schooling should be changed - not increased or decreased, but altered so that it fits the students.” She feels that their years of school should be the same as how academically smart they are. this already is confusing because if it can't increase nor decrease, then it can't be alter without change. If it should change, then how can it not decreased or increased. However, she supports her thesis with, 
"However, students are currently being assigned to "grades" based upon their age. They are expected learn at the same pace as the rest of their peers and to graduate to the next "grade" every year - their learning speeds are not taken into account."
This has confusion in it because of the fact that if they are assigned due to how they do well academically, then at what point should they stop going to school. When should they stop learning in order to move into working. learning at the same pace might give comfort to students because there won't be a hue age gap between the students of the same grade.
"This expectation eventually leads to negativity - students begin to compare themselves to their peers and forget to factor in their differing individualities. They feel superior when comparing themselves to less academic peers and inferior when comparing to more academic peers."
 This couldn't support her point well because the students will compare themselves either way, no matter how and where they are put. if it is based on academic level, they would still compare themselves to those who are higher than them and to those who are lower than them. It will increase comparison of students because the system of school year based on academic level can create a huge gap to those of the same age. Having to be in the same grade as someone who is the same age might give comfort to the student rather than being in a grade level with people of different age. The oldest in that class might feel really stupid while the youngest might feel super smart.
    In conclusion, Alyssa have strong points but it is not clear and there are many confusions with her points.

Sunday, January 23, 2011

Debate Topic: Is Wikileaks overall more harmful or more beneficial to society?

Wikileaks is basically a website where people everywhere can go online to see the latest news. It is a site meant to leak the truth out. They have “We help you safely get the truth out” in big blue font on their homepage. Many people consider Wikileaks as bad because it reveals stuff that wasn’t meant to be revealed. Well, I think that it is beneficial to society: our democratic society, and societies ruled by corrupted governments.
            America is a free country where the government is ruled by the people, a democratic government. The topic of whether or not political power corrupts those who attains it is related to this debate. If it is a government ruled by the people, then the people should at least know everything that the government is doing. There are no secret from the government and the people. Wikileaks helps keep the government in check. Our government would not be a democracy if the government has their own agenda and the people know nothing about it. It is helpful to us because we are in charge of our country and our government.
            Moreover, in other countries, it might also be helpful too because it gives a little confidence to the people to stand up for themselves and to do something about their corrupted government. It might also be a site that inspires people to keep their corrupted government in check. Just like the recent event of people setting themselves on fire and starting a rebellion because the news of their government was leaked out online. News of how corrupted the government was had been revealed and it angered many people. They couldn’t take it anymore to the point that one person set himself on fire. This might seem bad, but it revealed the truth that wasn’t meant to be kept a secret forever. If the truth wasn’t heard and people continued with their life, many people might suffer to death. It’s better to have people keep their government in check early than later. Worse things could’ve happened to those people if the corrupted government continues to rule. All in all, I think that Wikileaks is helpful to society in maintaining peace and giving people power and confidence.

Friday, January 14, 2011

seven debate response

After reading all seven of the debates, I found that all of them have errors and aren’t really persuasive but since I have to talk about one, I will talk about “Skip the Admission Game” by Kevin Carey. It really wasn’t persuasive and after reading it, I was confused on what it was trying to persuade. The first half of the article is about if a person is rich, then they should go to an elite school, while the second half of the article talks about how poor people should think of alternatives rather than try to go to an elite school. “If you're among the small handful of students who have stellar SAT scores and parents with several hundred thousand dollars to spend, you should seriously consider going to an elite college or university,” (Par. 1).This is one of the factors that I found unpersuasive because it’s like saying rich people should go to rich school while poor people should stick to poor schools. I feel that it is like trying to persuade people to continue to divide the line between the poor and the rich. Even though the poor may not have enough money, they can find other ways to allow them to go to an elite school. Moreover, Carey said, “If, on the other hand, you're not one of those people -- and the odds are very high that you're not -- your decision-making will be somewhat more complicated,” (Par. 4). It would have been a bit persuasive because not having enough money can be trouble in deciding but to say the odds of something and cutting off the thoughts of it sounded offensive to the poor. It also ignores the fact that there are scholarships that elite schools provide for trouble like money issues. Overall, this is the least persuasive article.
The most persuasive, the one that actually is a little persuading to me is the article “What You Do vs. Where You Go” by Martha(Marty) O’Connell. It is overall better than the rest though it does have factors that make it unpersuasive. Near the middle, she states, “The key to success in college and beyond has more to do with what students do with their time during college than where they choose to attend,”(Par. 4) with a source following it afterward. She cites her source as well as giving a link to it to show us that she isn’t making stuff up. it was somewhat persuasive because earlier in her article, she describes an activity that some people did and gives some examples of famous people who didn’t attend college.

Monday, September 13, 2010

Pro Death Penalty Rebuttal

Crystal Lau and Phuong Ha
Pro-Death Penalty Rebuttal

In the opening statement of our opposing team, Alyssa Li and Camal Saleh, they had claimed:
“There are endless sentences that could be put forth instead of the death penalty. If those who support the death penalty do so because they fear the suspect will be free again, why not agree to a sentence of life imprisonment without parole?”
When they had made this claim, they had failed to mention the cost of maintaining an inmate in prison. According to sources, the cost of keeping a prisoner in life without parole is roughly $50-60,000 per year with a 2% increase each consecutive year whereas the cost of executing a criminal is about $15 if we use a firing squad and $86 if we use lethal injections.

As their opening statement continues, the opposing side makes another faulty statement:
“The execution of a murderer brings back the principle of an ‘Eye for an Eye’ in which the great Ghandi once stated, ‘an eye for an eye leaves everybody blind’.”
According to this claim, they are making the assumption that everyone is committing a crime, which is obviously not the case. Therefore, how is it possible that it leaves everyone blind.

Moreover, they carry on with:
“ What if the supposed suspect is Innocent and is executed due to a death sentence? There is no way you can take back that mistake, a mistake you cannot fix once done?”
Once again the con side raises doubt without looking at the statistics. Based on the Death Penalty Information Center website, a total of 138 inmates have been exonerated from the death row since 1973. Out of these 138 cases, 17 of them were proven innocent through the DNA tests which is undeniable and solid evidence.
It remains clear that the opposing side makes baseless and faulty claims and fails to support their statements with solid proof. Everything that they propose is a philosophical “WHAT IF” and reality is not based upon doubts and questions but hard-core statistics. Due to the fact that simply their opening statement is full of flaws, it becomes apparent that their further arguments concerning the topic of capital punishment is also faulty. Consequently, it exemplifies that the death penalty should indeed be implemented as stated in our opening statement.